C$83 Cheap Flights from New York to Indianapolis

Compare New York to Indianapolis flight deals

Find the cheapest month or even day of the year to fly to Indianapolis

Book the best Indianapolis fare with no extra fees

Flight deals from New York to Indianapolis

Looking for a cheap last-minute deal or the best round-trip flight from New York to Indianapolis? Find the lowest prices on one-way and round-trip tickets right here.

Indianapolis.C$83 per passenger.Departing Tue, Apr 8, returning Wed, Apr 9.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from New York Newark on Tue, Apr 8, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from Indianapolis on Wed, Apr 9, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$83, select.

Indianapolis.C$84 per passenger.Departing Wed, Apr 30, returning Wed, May 7.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from New York Newark on Wed, Apr 30, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from Indianapolis on Wed, May 7, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$84, select.

Indianapolis.C$89 per passenger.Departing Tue, Mar 25, returning Wed, Mar 26.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departing from New York Newark on Tue, Mar 25, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departing from Indianapolis on Wed, Mar 26, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$89, select.

Indianapolis.C$101 per passenger.Departing Sat, May 3, returning Mon, May 5.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from New York Newark on Sat, May 3, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from Indianapolis on Mon, May 5, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$101, select.

Indianapolis.C$114 per passenger.Departing Wed, Mar 26, returning Thu, Apr 3.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departing from New York Newark on Wed, Mar 26, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departing from Indianapolis on Thu, Apr 3, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$114, select.

Indianapolis.C$133 per passenger.Departing Wed, Mar 19, returning Mon, Mar 31.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from New York Newark on Wed, Mar 19, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from Indianapolis on Mon, Mar 31, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$133, select.

Indianapolis.C$146 per passenger.Departing Wed, Mar 26, returning Thu, Apr 3.Round-trip flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from New York Newark on Wed, Mar 26, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound direct flight with Spirit Airlines departing from Indianapolis on Thu, Apr 3, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$146, select.

Indianapolis.C$149 per passenger.Departing Tue, Apr 15, returning Mon, Jun 2.Round-trip flight with Frontier Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Frontier Airlines, departing from New York Newark on Tue, Apr 15, arriving in Indianapolis.Inbound indirect flight with Frontier Airlines, departing from Indianapolis on Mon, Jun 2, arriving in New York Newark.Price includes taxes and charges.From C$149, select.

Find the cheapest month to fly from New York to Indianapolis

We’re always keeping an eye on fares, so you can find the best one in seconds. It looks like New York to Indianapolis flights are currently cheapest in April.

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Jan

Feb

Direct flights from New York to Indianapolis

New York to Indianapolis: Alternative routes

Compare routes from New York to Indianapolis below. You may find an airport to fly into that's cheaper, faster, or easier than Indianapolis.

New York to Indianapolis: Flight information

The things to know before you go.

Cheapest flight found	C$83
Cheapest month to fly	April
Average flight time	2 hrs, 23 mins
Most popular airline	WestJet
Average flights per week	476

Finding cheap flights from New York to Indianapolis: Frequently asked questions

How much are round-trip flights from New York to Indianapolis?

The best price we found for a round-trip flight from New York to Indianapolis is C$83. This is an estimate based on information collected from different airlines and travel providers over the last 4 days and is subject to change and availability.

How long does it take to fly from New York to Indianapolis?

2 hours and 23 minutes is the average flight time from New York to Indianapolis.

Which airlines fly direct from New York to Indianapolis?

WestJet, Republic Airways and Delta fly direct from New York to Indianapolis.

How many flights are there a week from New York to Indianapolis?

There are 476 flights per week flying from New York to Indianapolis, as of March 2025.

When is the cheapest time to fly from New York to Indianapolis?

The cheapest month to fly from New York to Indianapolis is usually March 2025.

Which upcoming date is cheapest to fly from New York to Indianapolis Airport on?

After crunching the numbers on our flight calendar, we found that it is currently cheapest to fly from New York to Indianapolis Airport on Tuesday, April 8, 2025.

Can I get a direct flight from New York to Indianapolis Airport?

Yes – the average flight time is 2 hours and 23 minutes.

When is the best time to book flights to Indianapolis?

We crunched all the numbers in our flight calendar, and it looks like the cheapest time to book a flight to Indianapolis is around 40 days in advance, so don’t leave your flight to the last minute.

Which is the cheapest airline to fly with from New York to Indianapolis?

The cheapest airline that flies to Indianapolis is Spirit Airlines.

How to find cheap flights to Indianapolis from New York

Looking for cheap tickets from New York to Indianapolis? Here are a few tips on how to secure the best flight price and make your journey as smooth as possible.

Simply hit "search." From Delta Air Lines to international carriers like Emirates, we compare all major airlines along with the most popular online travel agents to find the cheapest plane tickets from New York to Indianapolis. And with us, there are no hidden fees – what you see is what you pay.
Compare flight deals to Indianapolis from New York from over 1,000 providers. Then choose the cheapest plane tickets or fastest journeys.
Flex your dates to find the best New York–Indianapolis ticket prices. If you're flexible when it comes to your travel dates, use Skyscanner's "Whole month" tool to find the cheapest month, and even day to fly to Indianapolis from New York.
Set up a Price Alert. You can easily track the fare of your cheap New York–Indianapolis flights by creating an alert. Whenever prices go down or up, you'll get an email or push notification to help make sure you get the best possible flight deal.
Fly without stops. Only interested in direct flights between New York and Indianapolis? Make sure to tick "Direct flights only" when performing a search. If there are direct flights available on the route, these will appear in the results.
Find the cheapest Business Class flights from New York and Indianapolis. We scour the Internet for the best Business, Premium Economy and First Class flight fares to Indianapolis, too. Check the difference in price as you search – you might just stumble on a last-minute low fare. Note that not all cabin classes are available for every destination or airline.
Include nearby airports in your search. Widen your search for New York to Indianapolis flight deals by selecting the "add nearby airports" option. This will allow you to see flight prices for all the nearest airports at your departure point and your destination and could help you save the next time you travel.

Combine your flight to Indianapolis from New York with hotels and car rental

Once you've secured your cheap flight ticket from New York to Indianapolis, discover the best prices and exclusive rates for hotels in Indianapolis or nearby. You can also compare hundreds of car rental companies at once so you get the best car rental price for your trip.